September 18, 2007

If there’s ever been a confession there you have it.

Sir Brian Clarkson, the President and chief operating officer of Moody’s Investors Service in “Transparency and trust must keep on driving rating agencies” September 18, makes a confession that illustrates exactly the risks of securitization, meaning the packaging the selling and the forgetting of an investment by putting it on someone else’s book, and of the real danger of an excessive systemic reliance in the credit rating agencies criteria. He says” There have been allegations of lax underwriting and misrepresentations in subprime mortgage originations. There is no sure way for a rating analyst who is not involved in the loan origination process to detect such shortcomings.” With such a confession do we need more? Of course if a credit rating agency is to award an AAA rating based on the accumulation of a thousand individual mortgage loans, the least one could expect is a closer examination of some of them through a sampling process.
Nonetheless the real value of the confession lies in showing us how fail prone a system is when we are forced to trust someone, as is much the case with the credit rating agencies